The Chancy Now

There’s something so moving, and so mysterious, about the way Stead’s sonnets work across The Chancy Now. A triple gift: the gift of the poems themselves to the poet (they arrived “without any sense of an intention or change of plan”); the gift on display in the poems (Stead’s ear’s as good as ever, “sentences running free and summer’s here // for swimming”); the gift the poems then return to those that came before them, earlier works revisited and reworked by these late offerings. A whole new way of reading across the collections comes into view, these late works shifting and rearranging and putting into new balance some of the (for me) too-strident gestures of earlier poems. And the athleticism! This isn’t ‘late style’ as ‘bitter and spiny’ (Adorno’s description of Beethoven’s) but bouncy, agile, fleet, pacy. Stead calls himself a “hearer”, and it’s a pleasure to be his listener: “I love the pentameter” he tells us, and it shows. If the “sonnet’s secret is density, compression / words worked hard, your Muse made to sweat” then all of that, in the performance, comes out as aria parlante, “pure, effortless and lovely, // a gift of the gods”.

This tremulous cadence works to smuggle the “eternal note of sadness” in with its loveliness, though, and is all the more affecting for that. The “mystery of paternity remains” for grieving fathers and lost sons (we’ll all end up one or the other); the “wild winds” of family discord and misunderstanding (we all have those); the “ultimate weariness, just longing to be gone”. We all die either too early, or too late: there’s no in between. The details are particular and private and Stead’s but, in the transformation of art that turns “straw into gold” they are made somehow open, distant, impersonal. I caught myself weeping, reading these poems on the bus ride home last night, overwhelmed by rushes of feeling as the poem’s translated themselves into (real, or imagined, or anticipated) details from my own life. Like Curnow with his moon that “rolls over the roof and falls behind” his house, Stead talks most to me when he announces “I am talking about myself”. Another gift!

This collection tracks a poet “recklessly content” and pacing through “the chancy now”, moving between “the here and the there” and knowing always that the final “Otherwhere” is the next stop but, never refusing that reality, sustaining always the conversation across poems, writers, moments, lines. I’m going to try and get some of these poems into memory these coming weeks, held steadfast by their commitments to their art: “the tiny moths at night”

That waste their lovely wings on my desert air

should join with me to make a simple pact preaching neither faith nor hope, but fact.


Got to Serve Somebody

Reminders to myself before each election: “it might be the Devil, or it might be the Lord; you’ve got to serve somebody”. But also - and especially - “Who do you trust?". When it comes to voting I’m with Muddy.


The Threepenny Opera

A good night out over the weekend at The Threepenny Opera, Toi Whakaari’s graduating show this year. A show well done, some voicing wobbles in that cavernous space, to one side. It got me thinking, afterwards, though, about the play’s place in the canon now. What, in the era of Trump and the lumpenbourgeoisie around him, does Brecht have to say here? We’re in an age with perhaps an insufficient amount of hypocrisy. Look at it all, the script insists, and, underneath the fine labels and social niceties, it’s just power, violence, thuggery, sexual exploitation. Yes, it’s easy enough to imagine Trump, or JD Vance, or Pete Hegseth, responding: yes, we love it. This is exactly how things are.


Earthly! Ian Wedde at Eighty

And “what’s better to do than celebrate / the fact?” Ian Wedde turned 80 over the weekend and, last week, we were able to celebrate sixty years of poems at work. Ian came down from Auckland to read, and Jackson McCarthy, Sofia Drew and Anna Jackson all read poems of his alongside his own. There were lots of family members in the audience and lots of odes from the stage; it was joyous and fun, and gave me a chance to think on just how many of the poems have become a part of my soundscape (just as SYMMES HOLE still helps me think my way along the Waterfront towards Oriental Bay): when things are “earthly & difficult & full of doubt”; when it’s “lonely and afraid up here”; when Cambridge Terrace bustles with ‘good business’ and in “some ways I find hard to describe / I know it’s always been like this”; when recalling the “negligent mauve litter” of Auckland jacaranda; when driving into “the rainy architecture of the storm”.


“So what are those pleasures? What is the point? The core act of literary criticism sounds simple. It is sitting down with a bit of writing and thinking about it. Then there should be a head-exploding moment of making connections between its different bits and perhaps bits of one’s own experience or stuff that’s happening in the world now or which was happening in the world around the person who wrote it. Sometimes the thing you’re reading will seem baffling to start with. But the key thing to remember is that it once mattered to someone enough to make them shape it and write it down, so there has to be something there, even if finally you decide it shouldn’t have mattered as much as it did to the person who wrote it, or that it doesn’t really work. You might think about the way it manages to create a particular effect and you might learn how to write from thinking about the way it’s done (are there tricks, bits of compositional magic you can learn from?), or you might just feel a shiver at understanding something you never thought could be understood. Sometimes you get a sense of seeing someone else’s world, or a world you didn’t think was there. And once you have worked out a way of understanding the poem or the novel or the play then you have to convey it to someone else. A good critic is a kind of lightning conductor who picks out the energy in what they read and passes it to others.”

From Colin Burrow’s “Good Weird or Bad Weird”, a review of Helen Vendler’s last essays in the London Review of Books, 48: 16, 10 Sept 2026.


“Autofiction, first-person fiction, memoir, social media, and the personal essay compromise a continuum of auto-emission, indicating how much of literary production follows the human-capital ideology that makes of quotidian well-being a mandate to optimize one’s inner material and to actualize the self, and how much contemporary literature is constituted by its rejection of mediation. Streaming content free-flowing from free-lancers, auto-writing without “the distance between writer, reader, and critic”, writerly immediacy aestheticizes industrial conditions in publishing, which, as cultural scholar Sarah Brouillette points out, track closely with gigification and precaritization in other industries. Absent institutions like writers' guilds and staff unions, absent salaries for hours on background, absent knowledge protocols like investigative reporting or long-form synthesis, and drowning in student loan debt, content creators wield their only asset: expression of their inner life. Your story is something to own.” (101)

“Anti-mediation coalesces the literary field at present into a dominant style – one that converges hitherto-distinct genres of theory, fiction, memoir, the essay, and informal personal expression in a ubiquitous polyvalent writing. In the liquid emulsion of these modes, in their propensity for indistinct blur, in their churning flow, glides the writerly guise of propulsive circulation: frictionless uptake, fluid exchange, pouring directness, jet speed. Slick with this style, we may fail to read how the ‘auto’ of autofiction inscribes the self-manifestive quality common to the governmental ideologies of human capital, how the engulfing formlessness of genre melt ferries less the genius of authors than the flooded ruins of institutions like the university or the publishing house, how the defigurative realness of unadorned charismatic persons suffering execrably presages the dystopia already here. Immediacy as literary style holds incredible lure, but it sticks too close. In resigning the potential of writing to estrange, abstract, and mediate; in castigating the capacity of writing to collectivize and convoke; in deflating the power of writing to fabricate more than the immediately tangible detritus of evacuated sociality, immediacy writing collapses into self-identical emission: “This!”” (111-12)

Anna Kornbluh, Immediacy, or, The Style of Too Late Capitalism (London: Verso, 2023).


Reading: Hana Pera Aoake, writing in Overland, on the photography of John Miller. He “demonstrates what showing up and reciprocity looks like”.


“The author is not dying a second time. The author is splitting into two distinct figures with increasingly divergent social functions. On the one side, the Administrative Author: the person who holds the institutional position, the copyright, the reputational stake, the liability, without necessarily having performed the cognitive act that once gave those holdings their justification. On the other, something we do not yet have a fully adequate name for: the thinker who earns authorial aura precisely by demonstrating, in formats that cannot be faked or delegated, the capacity to engage with a problem frictively, in real time, at genuine intellectual cost.”

This from Anchit Sathi’s “AI and the Crisis of the Author”, a meditation on copyright law, ‘cognitive friction’, Barthes' call for the death of the author, Amazon’s meeting culture, and much else besides. I read it this morning and found it (usefully) troubling. Going onto the TLS website to provide a link I find this note: “We have removed this essay. AI was used in its preparation. The TLS editorial guidelines prohibit the use of AI in the writing and editing process. The author states that he was unaware of the policy.”


The accountability of language

I’m glad Alan Jacobs put a link to Wendell Berry’s “Standing by words” (1980-81) on his blog. I don’t know Berry’s work at all, really, and have been catching up as I can since the news of his death. These lines, ones Jacobs quotes, caught me too:

“glibness is an inescapable doom of language without standards. One of the great practical uses of the literary disciplines, of course, is to resist glibness — to slow language down and make it thoughtful. This accounts, particularly, for the influence of verse, in its formal aspect, within the dynamics of the growth of language: verse checks the merely impulsive flow of speech, subjects it to another pulse, to measure, to extra-linguistic consideration; by inducing the hesitations of difficulty, it admits into language the influence of the Muse and of musing.”


"Did you ever love somebody?"

Travelling Miles (1999) is the only one of Cassandra Wilson’s albums I’ve known well and had part of my life properly (“Right Here, Right Now” in particular). Her NYT obituary has me working through the rest of the catalogue, as does this quote: ““We live very segmented lives […] There’s Black music and there’s white music. There’s R&B and funk and whatever. This has always bothered me. People don’t see things in streams, they don’t see what tends to connect us all together. That’s what I see. That’s what I try to get at.” We need more handshakes, as Hone Tuwhare put it, in every cultural direction.


Uncle Vanya

Fires, floods, strained social orders, intergenerational struggle over property, lost standing, decay and unease . . . it wasn’t at all hard to find contemporary parallels in Uncle Vanya, opening at Circa last night (and running until 10 October, and worth your time), and Andrew Foster’s adaptation did nice working making the ‘scenes from country life’ ring from Chekhov’s day to ours. More important for me, thinking on the performance the morning after the night before, was the energy of it all. Carmel McGlone, surely one of Aotearoa’s best character actors, doesn’t have enough to do as Maria - blame Chekhov for that, but, and what she does do she does! As do Tawhi Thomas as Vanya, Kali Kopae as Helena, all six of the actors across the night.

All that great Russian gloom is translated somehow properly into a New Zealand gloom (Patrick White: “I shouldn’t be surprised if any New Zealander took a gun to his neighbour. Guns are to New Zealanders as axes are to Poles”)! It was oddly cheering, for reasons I don’t understand, to feel it all settle in and see it acted out so well. Disappointment; death; despair; discord. All the usual. I’m glad I went.


End-times fascism - “with its fortressed borders, decimated foreign aid and fixation on grabbing the resources beneath Greenland’s melting ice” as “a twisted and sadistic form of climate-change adaptation.” Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor in the FT. “Now that the reality of planetary heating has become undeniable, all that is left to deny is the humanity of our fellow humans.”


"the whole point is to do things the hard way"

Academics are especially susceptible to flattery, working, as we do, in such a hierarchical and status-obsessed profession. It’s no surprise then, really, that we’re prime candidates for AI blethers and its confidence men. All of that smooth language about efficiency and savings in grunt work and tedious tasks carries, just out of sight and not quite within reach, the promise that you’re too good for all of that. Tempting! But, of course, all of that is how we learn. And, often, what we learn too.

“The whole point is to do things the hard way, because that’s how you learn”, William Hubbard, of U of Chicago’s Law School, tells the FT’s Patti Waldmeir. I like the American sincerity of what he says next (and I believe him): “There are core aspects of the practice of law that are not about what’s in the books but what is in the human heart and soul. There is something very human about the lawyer’s job, someone is in a bad place and they know they have someone in their corner fighting for them.”


Dance-Floor Romance

Chris Tse’s (exuberant, glorious, poised, witty, wise) Dance-Floor Romance comes out this week, and I hope for it every success and well wish in the world. Tse has become one of our civic poets, making a space for his writing just to the side of the political and the demands of the moment and thus looking and listening in and on it in rewarding ways. It’s a role I never imagined for him as he set out (he’s a poet I don’t know personally at all, but I’ve bought each of his books as they’ve come out and have grown and changed as a reader under his tutelage), and one he’s made wonderfully his own. It’s a recognisable New Zealand and Bardic role (from Baxter in the 1960s to Wedde before the 1990s), but one now rightly different and distinct. It’s nice, this morning, reading Jackson McCarthy’s review (the book’s first?) and finding him responding to the _ourness _ of this mid-period Tse. Jackson hears the love chord sounding across Dance-Floor Romance as “a restatement of the lyric within the civic”. That seems right to me, and rightly put.

Mid-period Chris Tse puts me in mind of mid-period W.H. Auden. There’s a new relaxation and expansiveness, without ever loosening to slackness, complementing an earlier tension. There’s the sense of a public voice sounding itself in private places, and of private places being brought into public spaces. There’s a pleasurable delight in music and musicality, about the house and domestic without ever being fully domesticated and while staying knowingly unhoused. Tse is a poet aware of his place and of his responsibilities to place and to people, his head and mouth full of the noises and sounds and voices of his lands but prepared, on occasion, to talk back to them and to us. This collection, like Auden’s middle works, is comfortable in its own poetic skin and prepared to slip out of that skin when required. The verse is playful, toying, energetic, spry, sexy, winningly confident and charming and sly while also, like the rest of us, frightened, vulnerable, at risk. And it’s all………very gay.

There’s a pleasing sense across the collection of a poet aware of his skills and his craft and stretching himself out, trying a few new things, scratching some old itches and inhabiting a few different roles. There’s a tenderness and care on display (‘Please. Be here now.’) that was often kept fairly tightly constrained in the earlier collections. This is a collection of consolidation and expansion rather than a radical break or a new departure, but none the worse for that. The feeling of a deepened, more sophisticated, more rewarding and more extended encounter with interests Tse has had so far (ekphrasis, for instance, or engagement with pop music, or responses to other writers as interlocutors) make this a companion volume, and a companionable volume, to the post-How To Be Dead in a Year of Snakes Tse canon. Again, this brings Auden to mind: Tse is revising, reworking, developing sounds and images in a sound- and vision-world he has made his own, just as Auden’s great collections of the 1940s and 1950s peopled and populated (via opera rather than pop ballads, in his case) a fleshly, human, inhabitable gay world his earlier poems had longed for but never been able to wish into existence. I want to call the aesthetic on display here ‘tinkering’ without that term seeming belittling. Tse is in control of his inheritance: he is in the workshop, at play, busying himself with the tools to hand and knowing what to do with them. He is producing variations and, with each variation, a new pleasure and a new insight comes into view. Is it surrender or ecstasy? Yes, please.

This is clearly a collection by someone who has been Poet Laureate, without being burdened down by reading as a ‘Poet Laureate’s collection’. There’s an assurance to the voice, and (Auden again!) a nice and productive imbalance that comes in a few poems from speaking publicly in private (and privately in public), connected surely to the training and expectations of having functioned as a representative for Poetry across a few years. None of that should be mistaken for self-seriousness or absorption, but: when Tse steps in the room he can make the whole place shimmer.


above all this, I wish you love

“Farther along we’ll know all about it,

Farther along we’ll understand why;

Cheer up, my brother, live in the sunshine,

We’ll understand it all by and by.”


One of the pleasures for me in Emma Adler’s “Every novel is boring - until it isn’t” (at Public Books) is how contrary it seems to my own experience. Adler writes of the “volta” in a novel, a turn that, unlike the sonnet’s, is much more subjective and experiential, “a shift to visceral enjoyment” after the lulls of bored anticipation. It’s a smart essay, and a fun one. But surely also wrong! Oftentimes it’s the order and elegance and promise of an opening chapter, or opening sentence that engages me. Muriel Spark! “Daylight was appearing over London, the great city of bachelors.” And then, eventually, the realisation (or the inability to keep half-acknowledged) that I am reading “in anticipation of retrospection” sets in, and with it kinds of boredom or lagging attention. Even the best novels (like life) promise more than they can fully deliver. And every ending (again like life) is difficult because it brings to a close what, if we’ve been made a part of its reality, is the experience of the novel.


Ways of Seeing!

As the bus was between Gledenning Ave and Buccleugh St on North Rd this morning I turned to see Sacred Heart Church and, in the morning light, it looked as if Robin White had painted it, the hills and bush behind it, the hedge to its side. A man, troubled, got on at the next stop and, with his eyebrows and lined face, seemed as if he were a figure in a Jeffrey Harris painting. A glimpse through a window on the early part of the walk up North Rd showed a scene, ‘imagined in the context of a room’, as if framed by Joanna Margaret Paul.

If the poets teach the free man how to praise then the painters teach us how to see. It’s been a day when the gift of all of that seeing has been clearer than usual, and I’m grateful to them all.


good tidings for those who died stifled by unrelieved calamities

Would you like to learn how to utilise Co-Pilot, ChatGPT and Claude? I would prefer not to.

And Brad East reminds me that I am free to say “no”.


Sick at heart

Terry Eagleton, writing in COMMONWEAL:

“The scholarship boy typically feels that he has betrayed his parents, not that he has done away with them. Was I glad that my father was dead, as well as distraught? Was his end necessary so that I might begin? When I became a don I was the youngest fellow of my college since the eighteenth century, an era to which some of my colleagues seemed anxious to return. I had set my foot on the escalator that was to bear me up and away from the speechless man I had left on his deathbed. Then I moved to Oxford, uncertain whether I should reject the place in my father’s name or embrace it for just the same reason.”

I’ve not kept up with Eagleton’s books these past years, but I’ll be reading A DEATH OF ONE’S OWN.


The Cutting Edge

Nate Wooley’s tribute to Sonny Rollins at n+1 reminded me I’d never listened to anything more than Way Out West, and, to fix that gap, I’ve been listening to The Cutting Edge, a live album of Rollins at the Montreux Jazz Festival in 1974. And that (in the closing track, “Swing Low, Sweet Chariot”), took me to Rufus Harley, the only jazz bagpipe player I think I’ve ever heard. Glory be.